Showing posts with label greed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label greed. Show all posts

Friday, 12 April 2013

On Margaret Thatcher and empathy

Margaret Thatcher would have been delighted at the way her death is being treated by the left.  What better compliment could there be for the woman who did as much as she could to dismantle society into a collection of individual men and women than to treat her death as so important?

The neo-liberal project was and is all about shifting our thinking from empathy, from community well-being, from collective action and compassion for others to self-interest, to individual motivation, to all too often, greed.

So dismantling the collective provision of free health care, education, affordable and adequate housing, pensions, provisions for people who are caring for others – all of those mantras of Thatcher and co – while they open up opportunities for profit, also teach us not to care for other people.  Smashing unions, undermining collective employment rights and reducing unemployment protections  – while they keep those seeking and in work desperate to find and keep employment and vulnerable to exploitation, also create competition and antagonism between workers.  To say nothing of the othering of people on benefits which is an ongoing necessity to justify continued cuts to the most vulnerable people in society.

Thatcher

Margaret Thatcher would have revelled in the importance her individual death has been granted because it continues that placing of the individual above society, that privileging of individual agency over the importance of social structures, that she held so dear, that she championed so fiercely.

And she would have loved the lack of empathy on display.  Loved it.  Is there any clearer indication that the values of those seeking to destroy the social contract, seeking to promote selfishness and complete lack of collective responsibility, than the revelling in the death of an old, sick woman that’s been on display over the last few days?

Let’s tell the truth of Margaret Thatcher and other neo-liberals.  Let’s pay attention to her deliberate smashing of dissent by treating the British Police force as her own private army, criminalising protest activities and public gatherings.  Let’s notice that in Thatcher’s case her neo-liberalism was mixed in with social conservatism and nationalism with devastating results for the rights of all minority groups.  Let’s note the woman who hated beneficiaries was herself a beneficiary of the feminist movement, even while she trampled all over women’s rights.

By all means, let’s hate the neo-liberal project and the ways it has unleashed the disgusting, obscene gaps between rich and poor all over the western world by shifting our thinking from care, solidarity and collective responsibility to individual selfishness and greed.  Let’s keep organising, keep showing solidarity, keep championing compassion, equity and justice as guiding values for our society.

But I for one don’t want to celebrate her death, though I understand many, many others seem to feel that need.  She was just an individual, in a society.  And much as I detest her policies, I want to live in a world where empathy rules, not hatred.

Thursday, 24 January 2013

Let's talk about greed, baby

I've written before on why we should focus attention upon the powerful, rather than people who experience oppression.  Pretty much Changing the World 101 as far as I'm concerned.  Want to change domestic violence?  Dismantle masculinity constructs which equate power and control with being a man, and encourage ideas of relationships between whole people which involve sharing decision making and healthy autonomy.  Racism enraging you?  Examine the ways white privilege operates - then insist it is named and challenged wherever you see it, because every time we pretend something is racially neutral, we're probably perpetrating racism. 

We spend far too much time, when it comes to economics, talking about poverty.  We have all these narratives about it.  People who don't have enough are probably lazy, if not now then earlier in life.  They didn't try hard enough at school, or they take the piss at work.  They're probably drinking too much.  Look at the food they buy, that's disgusting.  Besides, they've got Sky TV/that flash jacket/new sunglasses every week/something I don't approve of them buying if they were really that poor......

Let's talk about greed.  In stats, because I like them:
  • The richest 100 billionaires in the world are worth $240 billion.  Oxfam thinks that's enough to END world poverty four times over
  • The richest 1% in the world have increased their income by 60% in the last 20 years.  The financial "crisis" has just accelerated this wealth grabbing
  • Here in Aoteroa, according to Stats NZ, the richest 10% get 25% of our total income, and own 50% of our total wealth
So let's talk about those rich people.  How they live, the choices they make, how they make such profits. Because if we did, I'm pretty sure there wouldn't be quite as many people out there prepared to put up with such a corrupt and inhumane way of organising sharing our resources.

Friday, 5 October 2012

What about the war on greed?

Welcome, those who do not agree with seeing those most impoverished in our society treated like the cause of the recession, to the National Day of Action Against Welfare Reform.  There are peaceful events protesting the Government approach to social welfare at WINZ offices around the country:

NELSON: WINZ 22 Bridge street contact: kayoss2@gmail.com or Facebook

DUNEDIN: Central WINZ Cnr St Andrews & Castle st contact (027) 259218 olive.mcrae@gmail.com or Facebook

TAURANGA: Spring street Tauranga CBD, Facebook.

KAIKOHE: Rally at WINZ Kaikohe contact: ketanasaxon@gmail.com or Facebook

AUCKLAND: Henderson WINZ contact unitewaimata@gmail.com or Facebook

WELLINGTON: Willis St. (Wellington City) WINZ contact Heleyni (029) 4949865, heleyni@unite.org.nz or Facebook

CHRISTCHURCH: Riccarton Rd WINZ contact joanna.wildish@gmail.com (022) 1726120 or Facebook

HAMILTON: WBAHamilton@gmail.com (022) 307 9324 or Facebook

HAWKE'S BAY: Hastings East WINZ Office. contact is msnhuata@gmail.com (022) 6014959 or Facebook

If you think making sure children in the poorest families in Aotearoa are not penalised by ideological decision making designed to stop us paying attention to who continues to be doing just fine during the recession, get yourselves down to WINZ.  See Wellington supporters there.

Monday, 28 May 2012

The problem is violent greed

Not for the first time, the genius of Jacky Fleming shows how skewed our world becomes when we focus on the wrong end of power and oppression:


Since coming into power, this National government has been near obsessed with blaming beneficiaries and the poor in general for all manner of wrong-doing.  Apparently cutting benefits is the "kick in the pants" some need to take responsibility for ​other taxpayers ​ (my emphasis). Paula Bennett has been quick to tell people claiming benefits - even ones she previously accessed herself - that "the dream is over."  If you have to visit a food bank to have enough to feed yourself and your family, it's because you've made "poor choices."

And step out of line if you dare, because Paula Bennett will release your personal details to the media as “a bit of a lesson for what happens if you go out there and put your story,” even if that does breach Privacy Commission ideas of fair practise to the tune of $15,000.  Nope, it's beneficiary bashing all the way, thanks.

You could be forgiven for assuming beneficiaries and the poor are sucking up resources unfairly, completely to blame for our economy stalling and many New Zealanders feeling frightened and even so hungry they eat pig scraps.

But what happens if we focus on the wealthy?

Firstly, they are doing pretty well under National, as this handy graphic from the Green Party shows:



And they are doing pretty well at the expense of everyone else.  Just 9% of New Zealanders are in the top tax bracket, so those tax cuts really were just for a few of us.  And while our median income is falling, our average income is increasing, which is just maths geekery for saying rich people are getting richer even in these belt-tightening times.

We don't spend enough time talking about greed in this country, because National has us bashing people with very little.  It is greedy to make sure those with lots of resources have the chance to create more and more and more, without thinking of ​other taxpayers ​(my emphasis).

If we focussed more on stopping those determined to create unnecessary wealth at the expense of everyone and everything else - the greedy 1% - and less on judging and punishing those with very little, our world would be a very different place.

Now I just need Jacky Fleming to write a cartoon about it.  Oh look, she has.